Metal detector vs X-ray for food inspection
Both protect your product, but they find different things. A metal detector finds metal. A food X-ray finds metal and also dense contaminants such as glass, stone and bone, even inside foil packs. The right choice depends on your product, your packaging and what could get into it.
Ask an engineer
Message us on WhatsApp.We're online now
Chat on WhatsApp- Talk directly to our engineers
- Price and options for your site
- No obligation
Need a formal quotation by email? Use our quote form
Get Quote now
Three details. No obligation.
Short answer
Choose a metal detector if metal is your main risk and your product is not packed in foil or metallised film. Choose X-ray if you also need to find glass, stone or bone, or if your product is packed in foil, cans or metallised film. Many factories use both: a metal detector early in the line, and X-ray on the finished pack.
Side by side
| Feature | Metal detector | Food X-ray |
|---|---|---|
| Finds | Ferrous, non-ferrous and stainless steel | Metal, glass, stone, bone and other dense materials |
| Foil, cans and metallised film | Standard detectors cannot inspect them; ferrous-in-foil detectors find ferrous metal only | Inspects through them |
| Wet, salty or frozen products | Can reduce sensitivity (“product effect”); multi-frequency detectors reduce the problem | Not affected by moisture or salt |
| Line types | Conveyor, free-fall and pipeline | Best on a conveyor at a steady speed; not suited to free-fall lines |
| Extra checks | Metal only | Can also check for missing items, counts and shape |
| Licensing in Sri Lanka | None needed for the detector | SLAERC notification and licence (unless exempt) and radiation safety; PBS prepares the documents |
| Cost | Lower to buy and run | Higher to buy |
Where a metal detector is the better fit
- Metal is your main risk, for example wear from machines, screens or blades
- Loose or bulk product before packing, including free-fall and pipeline lines
- Products in plastic film, paper or cartons
- Smaller budgets, with no radiation licensing to manage
Where X-ray is the better fit
- Glass, stone, bone or shell is a real risk, for example in jars, seafood, meat, nuts or spices
- Products packed in foil, cans or metallised film
- Wet or salty products where a metal detector struggles
- You also want to check for missing or broken items in the pack
What X-ray cannot see well
X-ray finds what is denser than the product around it. Materials close to the product’s density, such as some plastics, wood, insects or hair, are hard for any X-ray to see. For hair, insects and fine foreign matter in bulk foods such as tea, spices and grains, an AI colour sorter is often the better tool.
Using both
No single machine catches every contaminant. A common layout is a metal detector or metal separator early in the process, to protect machines and remove metal from raw material, and an X-ray on the finished pack, to catch what is left, including glass, stone and bone.
Not sure which you need?
We look at your product, packaging and risks, and recommend the right technology in a written site report. The LKR 25,000 + VAT visit fee is paid before the site inspection and then deducted from your final invoice amount. Book an engineer visit.
Radiation safety training for operators and RPOs, personal dosimeters, and the SLAERC plan, import approval and licence documents are included. See food X-ray inspection.
Metal detector or X-ray: common questions
Does X-ray replace a metal detector?
Not always. X-ray finds metal and other dense contaminants, but a metal detector is often still the better choice for loose or free-falling product and for smaller budgets. Many factories use both.
Can a metal detector inspect foil packs?
A standard metal detector cannot. A ferrous-in-foil detector finds ferrous metal only. To find non-ferrous metal, stainless steel, glass or stone in foil packs, use X-ray.
Do we need a licence for food X-ray in Sri Lanka?
In most cases, yes. Under the Sri Lanka Atomic Energy Act No. 40 of 2014, the Sri Lanka Atomic Energy Regulatory Council (SLAERC) must be notified and the practice licensed, unless the equipment qualifies for an exemption. PBS prepares the plan, import approval and licence documents on your behalf.
How do we decide which one we need?
Book an engineer site visit. We look at your product, packaging, line speed and audit requirements, and recommend the right technology in a written site report.
Request a formal quotation
Three quick details are enough to start. Add your product, pack and line speed if you have them and the quote will be exact. Your price is quoted for your exact project, so you never pay for options you do not need.
WhatsApp: 077 132 3424Call: 077 132 3424Email: pbs.metaldetectors@gmail.comBook an engineer visit →Book a consultation →